Claims     Request a Quote!
Call Us: (580) 889-3543

Customer Payment and Claim Center

Claims
Claims are the most important thing we handle at First Insurance. If you need to report a new claim, please call our office at (580) 889-3543. You can also report a new claim directly to your insurance company by following the company link below.

Payments
If you would like to make an insurance payment, please feel free to call or come by any of our locations. You can also make payments to many of our companies directly by following the company link below.

Below are links that you can use to make payments, access your policy, retrieve claim information and we have added additional forms for any questions that you may have.
 

Philadelphia
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-765-9749
Pacific Life
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-800-7646
MDOW
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 866-837-4668
Imperial PFS
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-791-7901
Humana
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-448-6262
Foremost
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-435-7764
CNA
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 877-262-2727
CIGNA
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-244-6224
American Strategic
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 866-274-8765
Allstate
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-255-7828
AM Trust
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 866-272-9267
American Modern
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-759-9008
AmeriSafe
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-699-6240
Arch Insurance
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 212-651-6500
Assurant Health
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-360-7071
BCBS
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: Visit Website
BCBS of Texas
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 972-766-6900
Berkshire Hathaway
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 888-495-8949
Burns & Wilcox
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: Visit Website
Chubb
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-252-4670
CNA Surety
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-331-6053
CompSource
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 405-232-7663
Cornerstone
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 888-735-5764
Delta Dental
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-765-6003
Genworth Financial
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 888-322-4629
Hallmark
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-486-5616
Hanover
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-853-0456
Hartford
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-327-3636
Hull & Company
* For Payments - Contact Agency
~ For Claims - Contact Agency
> Phone #: Contact Agency
Liberty Mutual
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-225-2467
Lloyds
* For Payments - Contact Agency
~ For Claims - Contact Agency
> Phone #: Contact Agency
Main Street America
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 877-425-2467
Markel
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-416-4364
MetLife
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-638-5433
Mutual of Omaha
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-775-6000
National Flood Service
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-637-3846
National General
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-325-1088
National Lloyds
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-749-6419
National Security
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-239-2358
NorthStar
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-622-5230
Old Republic
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-217-1792
Progressive
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-274-4499
Rain and Hail
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-776-4045
RLI
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-331-4929
Safeco
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-332-3226
Stroud
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-654-4056
Symetra Financial
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-796-3872
Texas Mutual
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-892-5246
TransAmerica
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: Visit Website
Travelers
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-252-4633
Travelers Business
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-252-2268
Travelers Flood
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-842-5075
Union Mutual
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 405-373-1760
United Healthcare
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 888-545-5205
Zurich
* Payments
~ Claim Information
> Phone #: 800-987-3373